Cheddar

Sharp Yellow Cheddar – Bold, Buttery, Beautifully TangyThe cheddar that brings comfort first… then delivers that satisfying sharp finish. Sharp Yel...

Creamy, Tangy, Boldly MeltableThe cheese that brings diner-counter comfort… with a sharper point of view. This Ultra Sharp American Cheese takes ev...

Creamy, Explosive, Not Here to BehaveThe cheese that looks like cheddar… then hits like a dare. This Scorpion Cheddar is for serious heat lovers on...

Cheddar Gruyere Black Truffle – Earthy, Nutty, Luxuriously MeltableThe cheese that takes one bite… and turns the whole moment gourmet. This Cheddar...

Tangy, Bold, East-Coast ClassicThe cheddar that keeps it cool… right up until that sharp New York bite kicks in. This NY Sharp is classic cheddar w...

Michigan Made Xtra Sharp White Cheddar – Bold, Clean, Unapologetically SharpThe cheddar that doesn’t hold back… and doesn’t need to. Crafted in the...

Bold, Buttery, Beautifully SharpThe cheddar that starts smooth… then lumbles into a rich, sharp finish you’ll keep coming back for. This 2 Year Age...

Sharp White Cheddar – Bold, Creamy, Comfort-Classic The cheddar that keeps it clean, then comes in with a confident bite. Our Sharp White Cheddar d...

Rich, creamy, and perfectly aged. Grab your Irish Cheddar for snacking, melting, and cheeseboards

Experience the rich and creamy Gouda flavor complemented by a blend of chipotle, habanero, and jalapeño peppers. With a balance of smokiness and sp...

Indulge in the decadent combination of creamy cheddar and gouda, perfect for satisfying snack cravings! We ship out on Mondays, Tuesdays, and Wedne...

Indulge in the ideal snacking experience with our blend of sharp cheddar, parmesan cheese, and gouda. Satisfy your taste buds with this dynamic tri...

Indulge in the bold and rich flavors of our Green Onion Yellow Cheddar. With a creamy and satisfying texture, this cheese is the perfect combinatio...

Indulge in the luxurious flavors of Mediterranean Sunset cheese, a blend of creamy white cheddar, and 12 exquisite spices and herbs. Savor its perf...

Indulge in the youthfully creamy and refined flavor of mild cheddar, complimented by the subtle sweetness and tang of fresh strawberries for a perf...

Crafted in Pinconning, this exquisite Colby-base cheese delights the senses with its sumptuous rich cheddar flavor. With age, its sharpness intensi...

This smooth, firm, tasty cheddar is made with Welsh brown ale and mustard seeds. Mustard & Ale Cheddar Cheese has a buttery and spicy cheese wi...

All of our aged cheddars come from expert cheese makers in Wisconsin. Availability in years & color may vary. We ship out on Mondays, Tuesdays,...

A standard mild cheddar enhanced with a touch of smoke. Use this to liven up your mac & cheese with a rich flavor. Pairs very well with red win...

Four distinct cheeses - Cheddar, Colby, Co-Jack, and Monterey Jack - present themselves upon a checkerboard plateau, poised to provide a sophistica...

This Garlic Cheddar Cheese is the perfect addition to any dish. Made with a bold dose of garlic, it delivers a unique and tangy flavor to classic a...

This yellow cheddar is made in the Amish country of Michigan! It has a medium bite, smooth and creamy flavor. It's a great cheese nestled between m...

This white cheddar cheese is made in the Amish country of Michigan! It has a slight sharp bite with a smooth and creamy taste. It's a mouthwatering...

This white cheddar is aged just over a year and is unusually sweet and moderately sharp. This is no tongue-searer but is best enjoyed with a stout ...