Skip to content

Cheddar

    • Best Seller
    Original price $12.99 - Original price $12.99
    Original price
    $12.99
    $12.99 - $12.99
    Current price $12.99

    Mild Smoked Cheddar

    A standard mild cheddar enhanced with a touch of smoke. Use this to liven up your mac & cheese with a rich flavor. Pairs very well with red win...

    View full details
    Original price $12.99 - Original price $12.99
    Original price
    $12.99
    $12.99 - $12.99
    Current price $12.99
    • Michigan Made Medium White Cheddar
      Original price $19.99 - Original price $19.99
      Original price
      $19.99
      $19.99 - $19.99
      Current price $19.99

      Michigan Made Medium White Cheddar

      This white cheddar cheese is made in the Amish country of Michigan! It has a slight sharp bite with a smooth and creamy taste. It's a mouthwatering...

      View full details
      Original price $19.99 - Original price $19.99
      Original price
      $19.99
      $19.99 - $19.99
      Current price $19.99
      • Best Seller
      Original price $19.99 - Original price $129.99
      Original price
      $19.99 - $129.99
      $19.99 - $129.99
      Current price $19.99

      Aged Cheddar 1-20 years

      All of our aged cheddars come from expert cheese makers in Wisconsin. Availability in years & color may vary. We ship out on Mondays, Tuesdays,...

      View full details
      Original price $19.99 - Original price $129.99
      Original price
      $19.99 - $129.99
      $19.99 - $129.99
      Current price $19.99
      • Original price $16.99 - Original price $16.99
        Original price
        $16.99
        $16.99 - $16.99
        Current price $16.99

        Mild Cheddar Cheese

        This yellow cheddar is mild with a great taste of cheddar that won't bite you back. It goes great on crackers with summer sausage, or melt on top o...

        View full details
        Original price $16.99 - Original price $16.99
        Original price
        $16.99
        $16.99 - $16.99
        Current price $16.99
        • Best Seller
        • Staff Favorite
        Roasted Garlic Cheddar
        Original price $15.99 - Original price $15.99
        Original price
        $15.99
        $15.99 - $15.99
        Current price $15.99

        Roasted Garlic Cheddar

        This Roasted Garlic Cheddar is made with a savory blend of aged cheddar and fresh fire-roasted garlic, making it sharp and robustly flavorful. Aged...

        View full details
        Original price $15.99 - Original price $15.99
        Original price
        $15.99
        $15.99 - $15.99
        Current price $15.99
        • Original price $25.99 - Original price $25.99
          Original price
          $25.99
          $25.99 - $25.99
          Current price $25.99

          Welsh White Cheddar

          This white cheddar is an English Cheddar with a distinct texture and slightly crumbly texture, yet smooth and creamy in the mouth. We ship out on M...

          View full details
          Original price $25.99 - Original price $25.99
          Original price
          $25.99
          $25.99 - $25.99
          Current price $25.99
          • Mango Fire White Hot Cheddar
            Mango Fire White Hot Cheddar
            Original price $17.99 - Original price $17.99
            Original price
            $17.99
            $17.99 - $17.99
            Current price $17.99

            Mango Fire White Hot Cheddar

            Mango Fire White Hot Cheddar is a deliciously bold cheese with a unique flavor. It offers a perfect balance of sweet mango and hot habanero pepper ...

            View full details
            Original price $17.99 - Original price $17.99
            Original price
            $17.99
            $17.99 - $17.99
            Current price $17.99
            • Original price $39.99 - Original price $39.99
              Original price
              $39.99
              $39.99 - $39.99
              Current price $39.99

              Mustard Ale English Cheddar

              This smooth, firm, tasty cheddar is made with Welsh brown ale and mustard seeds. Mustard & Ale Cheddar Cheese has a buttery and spicy cheese wi...

              View full details
              Original price $39.99 - Original price $39.99
              Original price
              $39.99
              $39.99 - $39.99
              Current price $39.99
              • Best Seller
              Frankenmuth Cheese
              Original price $12.99 - Original price $19.99
              Original price
              $12.99 - $19.99
              $12.99 - $19.99
              Current price $12.99

              Frankenmuth Cheese

              Crafted in Pinconning, this exquisite Colby-base cheese delights the senses with its sumptuous rich cheddar flavor. With age, its sharpness intensi...

              View full details
              Original price $12.99 - Original price $19.99
              Original price
              $12.99 - $19.99
              $12.99 - $19.99
              Current price $12.99
              • Terrific Trio
                Original price $29.99 - Original price $29.99
                Original price
                $29.99
                $29.99 - $29.99
                Current price $29.99

                Terrific Trio

                Indulge in the ideal snacking experience with our blend of sharp cheddar, parmesan cheese, and gouda. Satisfy your taste buds with this dynamic tri...

                View full details
                Original price $29.99 - Original price $29.99
                Original price
                $29.99
                $29.99 - $29.99
                Current price $29.99
                • Best Seller
                • Staff Favorite
                Mediterranean Sunset
                Original price $19.99 - Original price $19.99
                Original price
                $19.99
                $19.99 - $19.99
                Current price $19.99

                Mediterranean Sunset

                Indulge in the luxurious flavors of Mediterranean Sunset cheese, a blend of creamy white cheddar, and 12 exquisite spices and herbs. Savor its perf...

                View full details
                Original price $19.99 - Original price $19.99
                Original price
                $19.99
                $19.99 - $19.99
                Current price $19.99
                • Staff Favorite
                Red Fox
                Red Fox
                Original price $37.99 - Original price $37.99
                Original price
                $37.99
                $37.99 - $37.99
                Current price $37.99

                Red Fox

                Red Fox is aged for 16 months, resulting in a complex flavor that is both sweet and savory, with a hint of nuttiness and caramel. The cheese also b...

                View full details
                Original price $37.99 - Original price $37.99
                Original price
                $37.99
                $37.99 - $37.99
                Current price $37.99
                • Delicious Duo
                  Original price $24.99 - Original price $24.99
                  Original price
                  $24.99
                  $24.99 - $24.99
                  Current price $24.99

                  Delicious Duo Cheese

                  Indulge in the decadent combination of creamy cheddar and gouda, perfect for satisfying snack cravings! We ship out on Mondays, Tuesdays, and Wedne...

                  View full details
                  Original price $24.99 - Original price $24.99
                  Original price
                  $24.99
                  $24.99 - $24.99
                  Current price $24.99
                  • Best Seller
                  • New
                  Original price $24.99 - Original price $24.99
                  Original price
                  $24.99
                  $24.99 - $24.99
                  Current price $24.99

                  3 Chili Pepper Gouda

                  Experience the rich and creamy Gouda flavor complemented by a blend of chipotle, habanero, and jalapeño peppers. With a balance of smokiness and sp...

                  View full details
                  Original price $24.99 - Original price $24.99
                  Original price
                  $24.99
                  $24.99 - $24.99
                  Current price $24.99
                  • Chive & Shallot English Cheddar
                    Original price $39.99 - Original price $39.99
                    Original price
                    $39.99
                    $39.99 - $39.99
                    Current price $39.99

                    Chive & Shallot English Cheddar

                    This is a soft, semi-crumbly, English cheddar masterpiece, blended with small bits of fresh chives and shallots. The most incredible cheese that yo...

                    View full details
                    Original price $39.99 - Original price $39.99
                    Original price
                    $39.99
                    $39.99 - $39.99
                    Current price $39.99
                    • Irish Cheddar
                      Original price $29.99 - Original price $29.99
                      Original price
                      $29.99
                      $29.99 - $29.99
                      Current price $29.99

                      Irish Cheddar

                      This white cheddar is aged just over a year and is unusually sweet and moderately sharp. This is no tongue-searer but is best enjoyed with a stout ...

                      View full details
                      Original price $29.99 - Original price $29.99
                      Original price
                      $29.99
                      $29.99 - $29.99
                      Current price $29.99
                      • Simply Strawberry Cheddar
                        Simply Strawberry Cheddar
                        Original price $20.99 - Original price $20.99
                        Original price
                        $20.99
                        $20.99 - $20.99
                        Current price $20.99

                        Simply Strawberry Cheddar

                        Indulge in the youthfully creamy and refined flavor of mild cheddar, complimented by the subtle sweetness and tang of fresh strawberries for a perf...

                        View full details
                        Original price $20.99 - Original price $20.99
                        Original price
                        $20.99
                        $20.99 - $20.99
                        Current price $20.99
                        • Best Seller
                        Traverse City Cherry Cheddar
                        Original price $13.99 - Original price $13.99
                        Original price
                        $13.99
                        $13.99 - $13.99
                        Current price $13.99

                        Traverse City Cherry Cheddar

                        Experience the delicious combination of white cheddar cheese and dried cherries in Traverse City Cherry Cheddar. This unique cheese offers a hint o...

                        View full details
                        Original price $13.99 - Original price $13.99
                        Original price
                        $13.99
                        $13.99 - $13.99
                        Current price $13.99