Skip to content
To receive shipments by 12/25, place your order by 11:59pm on 12/19 for Michigan & northern OH deliveries and by 11:59pm on 12/17 for continental USA to be delivered by UPS.
To receive shipments by 12/25, place your order by 11:59pm on 12/19 for Michigan & northern OH deliveries and by 11:59pm on 12/17 for continental USA to be delivered by UPS.

Cheese

    • Best Seller
    • Staff Favorite
    Smoked Horseradish Cheese
    Original price $14.99 - Original price $14.99
    Original price
    $14.99
    $14.99 - $14.99
    Current price $14.99

    Smoked Horseradish

    This smoked version of our Horseradish American cheese provides a zesty, smoldering taste, ideal for an indulgent snack or for pairing with smoked ...

    View full details
    Original price $14.99 - Original price $14.99
    Original price
    $14.99
    $14.99 - $14.99
    Current price $14.99
    • Michigan Made Medium White Cheddar
      Original price $19.99 - Original price $19.99
      Original price
      $19.99
      $19.99 - $19.99
      Current price $19.99

      Michigan Made Medium White Cheddar

      This white cheddar cheese is made in the Amish country of Michigan! It has a slight sharp bite with a smooth and creamy taste. It's a mouthwatering...

      View full details
      Original price $19.99 - Original price $19.99
      Original price
      $19.99
      $19.99 - $19.99
      Current price $19.99
      • Best Seller
      Original price $11.99 - Original price $11.99
      Original price
      $11.99
      $11.99 - $11.99
      Current price $11.99

      Bruschetta Jack

      Introducing Bruschetta Jack, a delectably tangy cheese that combines the classic flavor of tomatoes, garlic, basil and parsley for a unique twist. ...

      View full details
      Original price $11.99 - Original price $11.99
      Original price
      $11.99
      $11.99 - $11.99
      Current price $11.99
      • Danish Blue Cheese
        Original price $21.99 - Original price $21.99
        Original price
        $21.99
        $21.99 - $21.99
        Current price $21.99

        Danish Blue Cheese

        This Danish Blue Cheese is a semi-soft cow's milk cheese, aged for an average of 10 weeks for its complex flavor. It has a compact, moist texture w...

        View full details
        Original price $21.99 - Original price $21.99
        Original price
        $21.99
        $21.99 - $21.99
        Current price $21.99
        • Original price $13.99 - Original price $13.99
          Original price
          $13.99
          $13.99 - $13.99
          Current price $13.99

          Yellow Cheese Curds

          Our yellow cheese curds are crafted with premium ingredients to provide a springy texture and classic yellow cheddar flavor. Each curd is character...

          View full details
          Original price $13.99 - Original price $13.99
          Original price
          $13.99
          $13.99 - $13.99
          Current price $13.99
          • Best Seller
          Original price $19.99 - Original price $19.99
          Original price
          $19.99
          $19.99 - $19.99
          Current price $19.99

          Carolina Reaper Cheddar

          This Ohio made cheddar is sure to set your mouth on fire! Excellent on burgers and meatloaf. We ship out on Mondays, Tuesdays, and Wednesdays to en...

          View full details
          Original price $19.99 - Original price $19.99
          Original price
          $19.99
          $19.99 - $19.99
          Current price $19.99
          • Smoked Mozzarella
            Original price $12.99 - Original price $12.99
            Original price
            $12.99
            $12.99 - $12.99
            Current price $12.99

            Smoked Mozzarella

            Smoked Mozzarella has a light golden brown outer shell and has an abundance of flavor. It's low moisture content makes it ideal for slicing and mel...

            View full details
            Original price $12.99 - Original price $12.99
            Original price
            $12.99
            $12.99 - $12.99
            Current price $12.99
            • Best Seller
            Original price $12.99 - Original price $12.99
            Original price
            $12.99
            $12.99 - $12.99
            Current price $12.99

            Colby

            Colby Cheese is softer, more moist, and milder than cheddar. It is a semi-hard cheese that goes well with summer sausage and crackers! We ship out ...

            View full details
            Original price $12.99 - Original price $12.99
            Original price
            $12.99
            $12.99 - $12.99
            Current price $12.99
            • Best Seller
            Traverse City Cherry Cheddar
            Original price $13.99 - Original price $13.99
            Original price
            $13.99
            $13.99 - $13.99
            Current price $13.99

            Traverse City Cherry Cheddar

            Experience the delicious combination of white cheddar cheese and dried cherries in Traverse City Cherry Cheddar. This unique cheese offers a hint o...

            View full details
            Original price $13.99 - Original price $13.99
            Original price
            $13.99
            $13.99 - $13.99
            Current price $13.99
            • Best Seller
            Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
            Original price
            $9.99
            $9.99 - $9.99
            Current price $9.99

            CoJack Cheese

            Co-Jack Cheese has an orange and white marbled appearance that is semi-hard with a mild flavor. It is commonly used on cheese trays, burritos, cass...

            View full details
            Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
            Original price
            $9.99
            $9.99 - $9.99
            Current price $9.99
            • Best Seller
            Tomato Basil Feta
            Original price $14.99 - Original price $14.99
            Original price
            $14.99
            $14.99 - $14.99
            Current price $14.99

            Tomato Basil Feta

            Experience the delicious combination of Tomato & Basil Feta Cheese. Crafted with premium quality part-skim milk and infused with zesty dried to...

            View full details
            Original price $14.99 - Original price $14.99
            Original price
            $14.99
            $14.99 - $14.99
            Current price $14.99
            • Smoked String Cheese
              Smoked String Cheese
              Original price $12.99 - Original price $12.99
              Original price
              $12.99
              $12.99 - $12.99
              Current price $12.99

              Smoked String Cheese

              Subtly infused with hickory smoke, this Mozzarella string cheese is an exquisite treat perfect for the sophisticated palate. Delight in the flavor ...

              View full details
              Original price $12.99 - Original price $12.99
              Original price
              $12.99
              $12.99 - $12.99
              Current price $12.99
              • Best Seller
              Havarti with Herb & Spice
              Original price $16.99 - Original price $16.99
              Original price
              $16.99
              $16.99 - $16.99
              Current price $16.99

              Havarti with Herbs & Spices

              Havarti with Herbs & Spices offers a unique, tangy taste experience thanks to its perfect blend of herbs and spices. This creamy yet mild chees...

              View full details
              Original price $16.99 - Original price $16.99
              Original price
              $16.99
              $16.99 - $16.99
              Current price $16.99
              • Best Seller
              Chipotle Jack
              Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
              Original price
              $9.99
              $9.99 - $9.99
              Current price $9.99

              Chipotle Jack

              Creamy Monterey jack cheese made with diced chipotle peppers. Enough heat & flavor to spice up a sandwich yet gentle enough to eat alone with c...

              View full details
              Original price $9.99 - Original price $9.99
              Original price
              $9.99
              $9.99 - $9.99
              Current price $9.99
              • Mango Fire White Hot Cheddar
                Mango Fire White Hot Cheddar
                Original price $17.99 - Original price $17.99
                Original price
                $17.99
                $17.99 - $17.99
                Current price $17.99

                Mango Fire White Hot Cheddar

                Mango Fire White Hot Cheddar is a deliciously bold cheese with a unique flavor. It offers a perfect balance of sweet mango and hot habanero pepper ...

                View full details
                Original price $17.99 - Original price $17.99
                Original price
                $17.99
                $17.99 - $17.99
                Current price $17.99
                • Original price $14.99 - Original price $14.99
                  Original price
                  $14.99
                  $14.99 - $14.99
                  Current price $14.99

                  Guggisburg Baby Swiss

                  This cheese has a mild taste and can be used in cooking! We recommend eating this with some crackers and salami. We ship out on Mondays, Tuesdays, ...

                  View full details
                  Original price $14.99 - Original price $14.99
                  Original price
                  $14.99
                  $14.99 - $14.99
                  Current price $14.99
                  • Best Seller
                  Original price $14.99 - Original price $14.99
                  Original price
                  $14.99
                  $14.99 - $14.99
                  Current price $14.99

                  Cranberry Cheddar

                  Crafted in Pinconning, this White Cheddar-style cheese is complemented with nuances of dried cranberries. A delectable delicacy, it is delightful t...

                  View full details
                  Original price $14.99 - Original price $14.99
                  Original price
                  $14.99
                  $14.99 - $14.99
                  Current price $14.99
                  • Original price $18.99 - Original price $18.99
                    Original price
                    $18.99
                    $18.99 - $18.99
                    Current price $18.99

                    Wisconsin Havarti Horseradish & Chive

                    Wisconsin Havarti Horseradish & Chive is a hand-crafted cheese made with a unique combination of flavors. Enjoy its buttery, slightly acidic ta...

                    View full details
                    Original price $18.99 - Original price $18.99
                    Original price
                    $18.99
                    $18.99 - $18.99
                    Current price $18.99
                    • Best Seller
                    Original price $17.99 - Original price $17.99
                    Original price
                    $17.99
                    $17.99 - $17.99
                    Current price $17.99

                    Tequila Lime Cheddar

                    Elevate your cheese experience with our one-of-a-kind Tequila Lime Cheddar. Immerse yourself in the tangy essence of tequila and the subtle underto...

                    View full details
                    Original price $17.99 - Original price $17.99
                    Original price
                    $17.99
                    $17.99 - $17.99
                    Current price $17.99
                    • Original price $16.99 - Original price $16.99
                      Original price
                      $16.99
                      $16.99 - $16.99
                      Current price $16.99

                      Wisconsin Sun-dried Tomato & Olive

                      Tomato Olive Cheese brings the taste of the Italian Mediterranean to your kitchen. This creamy Prairie Jack cheese is packed with sun-dried tomatoe...

                      View full details
                      Original price $16.99 - Original price $16.99
                      Original price
                      $16.99
                      $16.99 - $16.99
                      Current price $16.99
                      • Original price $26.99 - Original price $26.99
                        Original price
                        $26.99
                        $26.99 - $26.99
                        Current price $26.99

                        Mustard Gouda

                        The richness and punch of flavor that the cheese gets while it is maturing is intensified by the mustard seeds which add acidity and punch as well....

                        View full details
                        Original price $26.99 - Original price $26.99
                        Original price
                        $26.99
                        $26.99 - $26.99
                        Current price $26.99
                        • Original price $12.99 - Original price $12.99
                          Original price
                          $12.99
                          $12.99 - $12.99
                          Current price $12.99

                          Mozzarella Whips

                          Fabricated from premium mozzarella, these treats boast a supple yet resilient texture, enveloping palates in a pleasant, gentle, creamy flavor; ide...

                          View full details
                          Original price $12.99 - Original price $12.99
                          Original price
                          $12.99
                          $12.99 - $12.99
                          Current price $12.99
                          • Original price $13.99 - Original price $13.99
                            Original price
                            $13.99
                            $13.99 - $13.99
                            Current price $13.99

                            SMOKED PEPPERONI CHEESE

                            🔥 Smoked Pepperoni Cheese – Where Snack Meets Sizzle A smoky, spicy, sliceable party in a block. If cheese and charcuterie had a love affair, this ...

                            View full details
                            Original price $13.99 - Original price $13.99
                            Original price
                            $13.99
                            $13.99 - $13.99
                            Current price $13.99
                            • Brick Cheese
                              Original price $11.99 - Original price $11.99
                              Original price
                              $11.99
                              $11.99 - $11.99
                              Current price $11.99

                              Brick Cheese

                              Mild and sweet with a touch of nuttiness. Slice for sandwiches or shred for casseroles. A mild brick that goes well with Gamay Beaujolais or other ...

                              View full details
                              Original price $11.99 - Original price $11.99
                              Original price
                              $11.99
                              $11.99 - $11.99
                              Current price $11.99