Skip to content
COLBY PEPPER JACK

COLBY PEPPER JACK

$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99
$13.99 - $13.99
$13.99

Creamy, Marbled, Pepper-Loaded
Mild Colby comfort… with Pepper Jack heat baked right in.

This marbled beauty blends buttery-smooth Colby with zesty Pepper Jack, dotted with jalapeño (and sometimes habanero) peppers for a kick that wakes up your snack board without stealing the whole show. It’s creamy, sliceable, and melts into pure spicy goodness—perfect for sandwiches, burgers, and anything that wants a little swagger.

Tasting Notes:
Buttery · Creamy · Pepper-Bright · Gentle Heat Finish

Matilda-Approved Pairings

  • Sweet + spicy balance: honey, pepper jelly, fig jam, or apple slices

  • Crunch crew: pretzel thins, buttery crackers, tortilla chips (hello, instant queso vibe)

  • Melty missions: grilled cheese, burgers, quesadillas, nachos, breakfast burritos

  • Sips: crisp lager or a hop-forward IPA (bubbles + spice = best friends)

Why We Love It:
Because it’s the perfect middle ground—creamy and familiar, but with just enough pepper heat to keep things exciting.

Ingredients:
Commonly: pasteurized milk, jalapeño peppers (sometimes habanero), cheese culture, salt, enzymes, annatto (vegetable color) (varies by maker—check your label).
Contains: Milk.

📦 Shipping Info
We ship out on Mondays, Tuesdays, and Wednesdays to ensure the freshness of your product. During extreme summer heat, some shipments may be delayed to protect your cheese.
➡️ Multiple shipping addresses? Please place each order separately for now.

Shipping Information

We ship UPS anywhere within the USA. We take the quality of our products very seriously and want you to receive the best possible products, therefore we only ship perishable items Monday through Wednesday to allow products to arrive prior to the weekend. If overnight delivery is requested these orders can be completed through Thursday.

Customer Reviews

Based on 2 reviews
50%
(1)
50%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
T
Troy Johnson
Nice

Looks good

J
John Wayne
A story I wrote

One day John was walking to the cheese store because he needed 900 cheeses for his pet fish named Fish. Fish was not very smart because he lived in a bucket of elixer and thought the moon was a garlic finger.

Then John found a giant dodecahedron rolling down the road at 3 miles per banana. The dodecahedron said, "Hello John, I am Tres 4 and I need more cheese." John said, "Okay but I only have 899 cheeses because I accidentally ate one with garlic fingers."

Suddenly a cow pool appeared out of nowhere. It was a swimming pool full of cows. The cows were doing backflips and yelling, "CHEESE FOREVER!" Fish jumped out of the elixer bucket and landed in the cow pool and became mayor for 7 seconds.

Then Tres 4 tripped over a garlic finger and turned into a smaller dodecahedron. Nobody cared because they were busy making a cheese sandwich the size of a medium-sized volcano.

The sandwich exploded into even more cheese. John said, "This is the best and worst day of my life." Fish said, "I agree because I am a fish."

Then everyone ate cheese and garlic fingers until Tuesday. The end. Or maybe not because the dodecahedron was still rolling around somewhere saying, "I forgot my cheese."

THE END FOR REAL THIS TIME. Probably.