Specialty

Chocolate Cheese is a one-of-a-kind treat made with quality ingredients like cream, butter, sugar, cocoa, and Monterey Jack cheese. Its unique text...

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cheese is a one-of-a-kind treat proudly made "in haus". Boasting real cream, butter, sugar, cocoa, peanuts and Monterey Jac...

Indulge in the "in haus" flavor of Chocolate Mint Cheese. This rich and creamy treat is crafted with real cream, mint, butter, sugar, cocoa and Mon...

This smooth Holland made Gouda is lightly smoked and so delicious. Perfect for a meat and cheese board. Tastes great with a nut brown ale or amber ...

This Roasted Garlic Cheddar is made with a savory blend of aged cheddar and fresh fire-roasted garlic, making it sharp and robustly flavorful. Aged...

Smokey Swiss Cheese has a rich, smokey, melt-in-your-mouth flavor that's smooth and savory. It's enjoyable for snacking or a brilliant complement t...

Crafted with aromatic dill and a creamy, buttery texture, Havarti Dill Cheese is perfect for any occasion. Enjoy the bold notes while the soft and ...

This yellow cheddar is made in the Amish country of Michigan! It has a medium bite, smooth and creamy flavor. It's a great cheese nestled between m...

Pepperoni Cheese is a definite choice for the meat lover! A very smooth & creamy American-style cheese with pepperoni. We ship out on Mondays, ...

A standard mild cheddar enhanced with a touch of smoke. Use this to liven up your mac & cheese with a rich flavor. Pairs very well with red win...

Do you like grilled cheese? We can’t find a better cheese to stuff in between two pieces of buttered bread. Perfect for melting with a mild level o...

Introducing Bruschetta Jack, a delectably tangy cheese that combines the classic flavor of tomatoes, garlic, basil and parsley for a unique twist. ...

Pimento Cheese is a delicious cheese crafted with American cheese and genuine pimento peppers, offering a sweet and savory taste. This cheese is pe...

This smoked version of our Horseradish American cheese provides a zesty, smoldering taste, ideal for an indulgent snack or for pairing with smoked ...

Delight your taste buds with Green Onion Cheese - a creamy cheddar cheese with the sweetness of organic green onions. With its bright flecks of gre...

This Ohio made cheddar is sure to set your mouth on fire! Excellent on burgers and meatloaf. We ship out on Mondays, Tuesdays, and Wednesdays to en...

Check out our Salami Cheese! This cheddar base cheese has pieces of salami in it for a great taste overall! We ship out on Mondays, Tuesdays, and W...

Smoked Mozzarella has a light golden brown outer shell and has an abundance of flavor. It's low moisture content makes it ideal for slicing and mel...

Experience the delicious combination of Tomato & Basil Feta Cheese. Crafted with premium quality part-skim milk and infused with zesty dried to...

Havarti with Herbs & Spices offers a unique, tangy taste experience thanks to its perfect blend of herbs and spices. This creamy yet mild chees...

Creamy Monterey jack cheese made with diced chipotle peppers. Enough heat & flavor to spice up a sandwich yet gentle enough to eat alone with c...

Handcrafted in limited quantities, these syrups showcase only the finest of ingredients. They maintain their versatility whether used to top warm p...

Wisconsin Havarti Horseradish & Chive is a hand-crafted cheese made with a unique combination of flavors. Enjoy its buttery, slightly acidic ta...

Mango Fire White Hot Cheddar is a deliciously bold cheese with a unique flavor. It offers a perfect balance of sweet mango and hot habanero pepper ...

The richness and punch of flavor that the cheese gets while it is maturing is intensified by the mustard seeds which add acidity and punch as well....

A perfect union of four cheeses - cheddar, Colby, Co-Jack, and Monterey jack - evoking a symphony of flavor, seamlessly amalgamated yet adapted to ...

Tomato Olive Cheese brings the taste of the Italian Mediterranean to your kitchen. This creamy Prairie Jack cheese is packed with sun-dried tomatoe...

Tomato Basil Cheddar is a sharp medium cheddar, expertly crafted for a unique flavor experience. Enjoy the robust taste of tomato and basil, with s...

A smooth, rich Gouda cheese enhanced with fresh rosemary. Delicious for adding to a cheese-based sauce. Good enough to use for sandwiches or just o...

This smooth, firm, tasty cheddar is made with Welsh brown ale and mustard seeds. Mustard & Ale Cheddar Cheese has a buttery and spicy cheese wi...

Our Horseradish Cheddar Cheese is an irresistible combination of two classic flavors. Rich, buttery cheddar comes paired with the heat of horseradi...

  A tantalizing twist on Monterey Jack, Pepper Jack is enlivened with explosive notes of jalapeños and bell peppers. This semi-soft cheese is the p...

Mango Papaya Wensleydale is a hand-made Yorkshire cheese. It is made from milk drawn from cows grazing the limestone pastures in Upper Wensleydale....

Forwarding a taste of creamy, succulent dill-infused mozzarella, this soft cheese is a luxurious indulgence. We ship out on Mondays, Tuesdays, and ...

Primosale is charmed by a bright, fresh aroma, and is replete with a sweet milky taste. Made from whole sheep's milk,  olives, arugula and peppers ...

Indulge in our selection of gourmet flavors, from hickory to spicy. These pork and sausage based snack sticks are expertly crafted with premium spi...

Semi-hard yet creamy, Havarti cheese is a tantalizingly indulgent experience. It captivates with its nuanced flavors of sweetness and slight acidit...

Experience the ultimate indulgence for any outdoor lover. With a flawless blend of rich, succulent elk and savory pork, complemented by a refined m...

This cheese has a mild and smoky flavor. The slightly smoky, slightly nutty taste lends a great taste for snacking. It adds delicious interest to f...

Crafted in Pinconning, this White Cheddar-style cheese is complemented with nuances of dried cranberries. A delectable delicacy, it is delightful t...

Our Michigan Truffle cheese is sure to tantalize with its rich flavor, created by combining black truffle peelings and white truffle oil. Try it in...

This is a soft, semi-crumbly, English cheddar masterpiece, blended with small bits of fresh chives and shallots. The most incredible cheese that yo...

Experience the flavor of freshly-harvested pecans and apples with our Apple Pecan Dressing. Bursting with ripe apples and crunchy Southern pecans, ...

Experience cheese perfection with The Big Moo baked cheese, crafted from fresh Wisconsin Creamline milk. Whether seared, grilled, or baked, THE BIG...

A Colby Jack cheese, enhanced with smoky pepperoni dice and natural smoke flavoring, Pepperoni Marble is a flavor and texture combination that pair...

This luxurious cheddar provides an exquisite, velvety flavor amalgamated with the succulence of ripened blueberries and the subtle taste of mild ch...

Indulge in the luxurious essence of Sweet Fire Mango Jack, an exquisite blend of semi-soft Monterey Jack infused with the tantalizing notes of mang...

Exquisitely crafted by hand in small quantities for a pure flavor, this jam is made from the ripest of fruits and unrefined cane sugar; spread it g...