Spicy

Do you like grilled cheese? We can’t find a better cheese to stuff in between two pieces of buttered bread. Perfect for melting with a mild level o...

Mango Fire White Hot Cheddar is a deliciously bold cheese with a unique flavor. It offers a perfect balance of sweet mango and hot habanero pepper ...

  A tantalizing twist on Monterey Jack, Pepper Jack is enlivened with explosive notes of jalapeños and bell peppers. This semi-soft cheese is the p...

Turn up the heat with Desert Fire cheese! This creamy, spicy blend is packed with jalapeño peppers and a fiery kick from oleoresin capsicum. Perfec...

Experience the rich and creamy Gouda flavor complemented by a blend of chipotle, habanero, and jalapeño peppers. With a balance of smokiness and sp...

This Ohio made cheddar is sure to set your mouth on fire! Excellent on burgers and meatloaf. We ship out on Mondays, Tuesdays, and Wednesdays to en...

Creamy Monterey jack cheese made with diced chipotle peppers. Enough heat & flavor to spice up a sandwich yet gentle enough to eat alone with c...

This yellow cheddar cheese is creamy with the heat of a buffalo wing sauce. On a scale of 1 - 10 with 10 being most hot, this is about a 8. It's gr...

Experience the fiery and smoky flavors of Ghost Pepper Cheese. This unique cheese boasts a variety of spice profiles but be prepared for an intensi...

Sriracha Jack Cheese – Creamy, Fiery, Crave-WorthyThe mellow Jack that fell in love with hot sauce. This is what happens when smooth, melty Montere...

Tangy, Creamy, Game-Day LoudAll the Buffalo wing vibes… in a sliceable, meltable cheese. This one’s built for snack boards that don’t play it safe....

Creamy, Marbled, Pepper-LoadedMild Colby comfort… with Pepper Jack heat baked right in. This marbled beauty blends buttery-smooth Colby with zesty ...

Creamy, Zesty, Fresh-Herb HeatBright jalapeño kick… cooled by creamy comfort and a pop of garden-fresh cilantro. This cheese is all about balance: ...

Creamy, Marbled, Fearlessly SpicyThe cheese that starts smooth… then makes your taste buds do cartwheels. Jumping Jack is a marbled Colby + Montere...

Creamy, Fiery, Crowd-WakeningThe cheese that starts smooth… then turns up the heat and never looks back. This Habanero Pepper cheese brings that pe...

Creamy, Pepper-Packed, Beautifully UnrulyThe cheese that looks friendly… then brings the heat like it has something to prove. This Muscoda Mayhem C...

Creamy, Explosive, Not Here to BehaveThe cheese that looks like cheddar… then hits like a dare. This Scorpion Cheddar is for serious heat lovers on...

🌶️ Chipotle Pepper Cheddar – Smoky Heat Meets Creamy Boldness This cheddar came to spice things up. Our Chipotle Pepper Cheddar is not your average...

Creamy, Smoky, Gently SpicyThe cheese that keeps things smooth… then sneaks in a little heat just to keep you paying attention. This Smoked Gouda w...

Smoky, Creamy, Fire-KissedThe cheese that starts smooth… then brings the smoke, the spice, and absolutely no regrets. This Smoked Habanero Jalapeño...

Creamy, Smoky, Heat-LacedThe cheese that plays it cool at first… then lets the smoke and spice do the talking. This Smoked Hot Pepper cheese brings...

Smoky, Creamy, Full-Throttle HeatThe cheese that looks like a good time… then turns into a whole weather event. This Smoked Thunder Jack is built f...

Rev up your taste buds with Habanero Muenster a fusion of fiery habanero and jalapeño peppers. Indulge in the bold and smooth flavors on a sandwich...

Check out this spicy cheese with just enough heat to drive your tastebuds wild! We ship out on Mondays, Tuesdays, and Wednesdays to ensure the fres...